The 7 Best Places to Grab a Burger in Toledo

While we tend to experience cravings for all types of food come lunch or dinner time, it seems as though burger cravings occur a little more often. It might be the juicy meat patty, the flavorful toppings, or the freshly baked burger bun — or simply the combination of all three.

Are you hungry yet? If not, you will be by the end of this.

These cravings often creep up on us and we’re stuck with a burger-shaped hole in our stomach with no place to go. What a hopeless feeling! To avoid such panic during your next burger craving, simply consult this list of the best places to grab a burger in Toledo!


Indulge in the Apple Pie Burger at Bar 145

Bar 145 Apple Pie Burger

Photos Courtesy of Bar 145.

Hours: Monday–Thursday 11:30 a.m.–10 p.m., Friday & Saturday 11:30 a.m.–11 p.m. and Sunday 11:30 a.m.–9 p.m.
Location: 5305 Monroe Street, Toledo, OH 43623

Bar 145 specializes in burgers, bands and bourbon. If one-third of their business centers around our beloved burger, we’re in. In fact, their very name has to do with burgers, as 145 degrees is the temperature of a perfectly cooked medium rare burger.

Check out their menu packed with burgers, bourbon cocktails, and even an option for stacking your own burger! Don’t miss their apple pie burger — an extremely unique and delicious option.

Burger Bar 419’s Musty Have Burger is a Must-Have

Burger Bar 419 Toledo

Photos Courtesy of Burger Bar 419.

Hours: Sunday–Wednesday 11:30 a.m.–10 p.m., Thursday–Saturday 11:30 a.m.–11 p.m.

Location: 4400 Heatherdowns Boulevard, Toledo, OH 43614

While we’ve already addressed Burger Bar 419’s knack for cocktail creation, we’d also love to draw attention to their ability to craft an exceptional burger. It is, in fact, implied in their name!

Using fresh, locally ground beef to craft their patties, Burger Bar 419 has a large selection of unique burger options. Their “Musty Have” burger is comprised of bibb lettuce, grilled tomato, taleggio cheese, portabella mushrooms and balsamic-glazed red onion. Or try their Marinated Mushroom burger with two full Portabella mushroom caps, arugula, grilled tomato and brie cheese.

Order the Bacon Mushroom Melt Burger from Berger’s Olde Tyme Grill

Berger's Olde Tyme Grill

Photos Courtesy of Berger’s Olde Tyme Grill.

Hours: Monday–Thursday 10 a.m.–10:30 p.m., Friday & Saturday 10 a.m.–11:30 p.m. and Sunday 12–10:30 p.m.

Location: 1742 West Laskey Road, Toledo, OH 43613

Many consider Berger’s Olde Tyme Grill the “Best Burgers in Town,” and for good reason! They have been serving up great food since they opened their doors in 1993. This family-owned burger joint was the winner of Toledo City Paper’s Best Burger award in both 2008 and 2010. Order the popular Bacon Mushroom Melt Burger from the “Specialty Burger” section of their menu or keep things simple with their fresh hand-pattied half-pound ground beef burger served with chips and loaded with all the fixings.


Grab a Zorba Burger at Nick & Jimmy’s

Nick and Jimmy's Toledo

Photos Courtesy of Nick & Jimmy’s.

Hours: Monday & Tuesday 7 a.m.–1 a.m., Wednesday–Friday 7 a.m.–2:30 a.m., Saturday 7 a.m.–12 a.m., Closed Sunday

Location: 4956 Monroe Street, Toledo, OH 43623

The ultimate companion for a delicious burger is a cold, refreshing glass of beer. Thankfully, Nick & Jimmy’s has both mastered. They have even been considered Toledo’s best burger for 32 years! Try the Zorba burger off their burger menu, and try not to break out in a dance (they even warn you in the fine print). All of their burgers are made fresh, with 8-ounce handmade ground sirloin patties. And if you stop by Nick & Jimmy’s on a Tuesday, you’re in luck! They offer $2.50 burgers to celebrate “Retro Tuesday.”


Try the Angus Burger at Grumpy’s Restaurant

Grumpy's Toledo

Photos Courtesy of Grumpy’s Restaurant.

Hours: Monday–Friday 8 a.m.–2 p.m., Closed Saturday & Sunday

Location: 34 South Huron Street, Toledo, OH 43604

We love Grumpy’s motto — Eat Here & Diet Home. This is a family-owned restaurant the town of Toledo has grown to love for over the past 30 years. Track down their “Grumpy’s On the Go” food truck, or visit their brick-and-mortar location downtown. While their menu covers many food genres, we particularly enjoy their burgers — and the angus burger is especially tasty! Don’t let their short list of burgers fool you; Grumpy’s values quality over quantity.


Bite into Maumee Bay Brewing Co.’s Ghost Burger

Maumee Bay Brewing Co. Toledo

Photos Courtesy of Maumee Bay Brewing Co. and TripAdvisor.

Hours: Monday–Thursday 3–10 p.m., Friday & Saturday 3–11 p.m., Sunday 12–8 p.m.

Location: 27 Broadway Street, Toledo, OH 43604

Maumee Bay Brewing Co. is located in the historic Oliver House and stands strong as Toledo’s oldest brewery. While we all know Maumee Bay Brewing Co. is a prominent figure in the local craft beer scene, you may not realize they offer some amazing burgers as well. During your next visit, order the ghost burger filled with guacamole, sweet spicy bacon, and ghost pepper jack cheese.


Try the Wimpy Burger at Schmucker’s Restaurant

Schmucker's Wimpy Burger

Photos Courtesy of Schmucker’s Restaurant.

Hours: Monday–Saturday 5 a.m.–11 p.m., Closed Sunday

Location: 2103 North Reynolds Road, Toledo, OH 43615

Step into the past with a visit to Schmucker’s Restaurant on Reynolds Road, where they’ve been located since 1948. This family-owned restaurant has a rich history and simply hasn’t changed much over the years, sticking to their wonderful traditions and quality food. Order a homemade burger off their lunch and dinner menu, paying special attention to their Wimpy Burger, which is anything but wimpy with its double dosage of patties and all the fixings.

Happy burger hunting, Toledo!

Let us know which local establishment offers your favorite burger in town, and we just might add it to our list!


Written: Mar 30, 2016

About The Author

Holly Ragsdale

Holly Ragsdale

Holly is a content specialist for Danberry Realtors. The Home Sweet Toledo blog focuses on community guides + local events, as well as home inspiration + design trends. Enjoy!